Philanthropy must go beyond charity to fund transformational food system change

SAFSF - On October 22, 2020, the Global Solidarity Alliance for Food, Health and Social Justice urged members of the Sustainable Agriculture and Food System Funders (SAFSF) to go beyond charity and work toward transformational food system change through the first of a two-part webinar series titled: "We Can't 'Foodbank' Our way Out of Hunger."

Alison Cohen (Why Hunger), Joshua Lohnes (WVU Center for Resilient Communities), Robert Ojeda (Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona) and Shakara Tyler (Detroit Black Community Food Security Network) offered their thoughts on the limits of the current food banking model, its relationship to exploitative agro-industrial food systems and the need to go beyond charity to ensure the right to food.

A letter written by the alliance, and signed by over one hundred anti-hunger and food system practitioners, activist, and scholars, urges the philanthropic community to consider the following six key principles when approaching their investments in food access and food system development work:

1. Commit to organizations in a spirit of slow philanthropy with the understanding that food system transformation is a long-term commitment to social change.

reduce data collection demands, including monitoring and evaluation pressures, on front-line organizations serving those in need.

standardize data collection practices across public and private funding networks

2. Commit to projects and policy that shorten food bank lines through emphasizing the realization of the right to food, income security and investing in community wealth building projects

3. Commit to grassroots organizations working to address the root causes of food system inequity

projects led by people from Black, Indigenous and other historically marginalized and oppressed communities.

projects that abide by principles of democratic decision making.

projects that prioritize agroecology and climate justice.

projects that prioritize the equitable redistribution of wealth

4. Commit to strengthening networks that contribute to the resilience of regional food systems

5. Commit to strengthening networks that build power from the bottom up to reshape food policies that serve people over profit

6. Commit to funding organizations that involve experts-by-experience in decision making and governance structures.

The four panelists facilitated break-out conversations with participants about the limits and opportunities of implementing these principles in their work. While the majority of the participants resonated with the principles, they expressed a number of challenges ahead with implementation including:

Primary focus on immediate needs

Board resistance

The normalization of food assistance in society

Funder demands for quantitative impact models

Need to educate donors and funders on the root causes of hunger

Intimidating ideas for those in positions of privilege

Difficulty weaving the principles into formalized RFP process

Lack of trust-based models in philanthropic giving

Entrenched power structures in the philanthropic sector

Difficult to find opportunities to hear from impacted people and organizations

Intermediaries must often broker relationships between funders and organizations